Rejecting trademarks that 'disparage' others violates First Amendment
Rejecting trademarks that 'disparage' others violates First Amendment
20 June, 2017, 00:28
The Supreme Court of the United States decided in the case ofMatal v. Tam Monday to strike down a key provision of the Lanham Act barring the United States Patent and Trademark Office from recognizing a disparaging trademark, citing concerns that the act violated the First Amendment.
The trademark office in 2011 said registering the trademark of the Slants, an Asian American rock group, would violate a part of the 1946 Lanham Trademark Act that prohibits registration of a trademark that "may disparage. persons, living or dead, institutions, beliefs, or national symbols, or bring them into contempt, or disrepute".
"The government defends free speech around the world because it knows when free speech is threatened, religious minorities suffer", said Hannah Smith, senior counsel at Becket, a non-profit religious liberty law firm that says it has teamed with the government in the past to fight laws banning insulting or defaming religious speech.
Supreme Court rejected an appeal from the Redskins trademark case in October, denying the petition for review before a lower court had a chance to rule on the matter.
The justices were unanimous in saying that the 71-year-old trademark law barring disparaging terms infringes free speech rights guaranteed in the Constitution's First Amendment. "It offends a bedrock First Amendment principle: Speech may not be banned on the ground that it expresses ideas that offend". He has called the Redskins' name a "badge of honor". A federal appeals court in Richmond put the team's case on hold while waiting for the Supreme Court to rule in the Slants case.
But the Federal Circuit, ruling on the Slants' case in December 2015, overturned that precedent, declaring that the rule penalized unpopular speech by denying the substantial benefits of a trademark registration.
Redskins owner Dan Snyder has repeatedly said that he will not change the nickname despite the opposition.
He says he picked his band's moniker in an effort to reclaim a stereotype.
The ruling likely paves the way for the Redskins to protect trademarks covering the team's name. Snyder issued a quick response to the decision on Monday: "I am THRILLED". Alito also said trademarks are not immune from First Amendment protection as part of a government program or subsidy.
But when the litigation of the word "redskins" is left to a group like the PTO, the resulting decisions will always say more about that body's own biases than anything else.
Band members also dedicated their new release, "The Band Who Must Be Named", as an "open letter to the United States Patent and Trademark Office to articulate these values".
Critics of the law said the trademark office has been wildly inconsistent over the years in deciding what terms are too offensive to warrant trademark protection. Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote a separate opinion and was joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan. The decision could destroy legal challenges to other controversial trademarks, such as the Washington Redskins football team. The band's lawyers argued that the government can not use trademark law to impose burdens on free speech to protect listeners from offense.
Well now, Scarlett Johansson met her doppelgänger, according to Entertainment Weekly , and they had a blast. This came to me purely because people were like, 'Oh my God, you have a doppelganger and it's insane .
The euro, after earlier rising to its highest level against the dollar since November 9, was last little changed at $1.1215. Analysts had forecast that U.S. inflation would slow from 2.2% to 2% year-on-year and from 0.2% to 0.1% month-on-month.
Fowler and Reed will command plenty of attention, but do not discount Kim Si-woo, who sits between the American duo at nine under. The much-maligned site of this year's national championship has been giving up birdies and low scores, very unlike a U.S.
Real Madrid were rocked by widespread claims in the media on Friday that Ronaldo wants to leave the Spanish capital in the summer. United had been favourites to sign the Spain worldwide , with a £65m deal appearing close to completion last week.
The deal comes just weeks after Trump signed a deal with Saudi Arabia for nearly $110 billion in United States arms. United States and Qatar signed an agreement to purchase the last American F-15 fighters worth $ 12 billion.
Brent crude, used to price worldwide oils, climbed 45 cents, or 1 percent, to $47.37 a barrel in London. AAA reports that the most expensive gasoline can be found in the City of Chicago, at $2.73 per gallon.
Talking to media after the team outclassed India , skipper Sarfraz said that the perception about Pakistan team should be changed. Just two weeks ago, Pakistan were at a low ebb after crashing to a humiliating 124-run defeat against India in the group stage.
Jo Cox's widower has said his family has not been broken by her murder ahead of the first anniversary of the MP's death. The Great Get Together has also organised rivals to work together temporarily for the event.
WH: Trump Has 'No Intention' of Firing Mueller
Ruddy was at the White House on Monday to meet White House aides, but did not speak with the president, Spicer said. Ruddy did not dismiss the White House communications team's words, but he did call Spicer's statement "bizarre".
Driver plows into crowd outside London mosque, injuring 10
Opposition Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn said on Twitter: "I'm totally shocked at the incident at Finsbury Park". On May 22, a suicide attack killed 22 people and injured almost 60 after an Ariana Grande concert in Manchester .
The wrong kind of US Open history: Top 3 all miss cut
It's there that the mistake was made: Hadwin tried to play too ideal of a third shot up toward the raised putting surface. It was the first time since the world ranking began in 1986 that the top three players missed the cut in any major.
Patty Jenkins has mixed feelings about women-only Wonder Woman
Went to the garden to get some fresh air with my coffee to help me wake up and now watching The Cat In The Hat with my daughter. As Glamour recalled in a 2016 article, Gal Gadot met her husband, an Israeli businessman, at a "very odd party" in the desert.
Harman looks for major breakthrough at US Open
Open is wide open going into the weekend. - Leader Brian Harman reflects on unusual scoring conditions this week. He has birdied three of his last four holes. 1, 7 and 9 on the front nine and three in a row on Nos.
Prosecutors say they'll retry Bill Cosby
The Associated Press does not typically identify people who say they are victims of sexual assault unless they grant permission. After multiple attempts for the jury to come to a verdict, the judge has chose to consider the Bill Cosby case a mistrial .
58 presumed dead in London tower fire
London Fire Commissioner Dany Cotton said her crews had identified a "number" of those killed, "but we know there will be more". Scotland Yard is leading the criminal investigation into the fire at Grenfell Tower to establish the exact cause of the fire.