Tuesday, 18 February, 2020
  • National
  • Supreme Court Strikes Down Gender-Based Citizenship Law

Supreme Court Strikes Down Gender-Based Citizenship Law

Mark Wilson Getty Images Mark Wilson Getty Images
Kelley Robertson | 13 June, 2017, 08:28

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday struck down a gender distinction in U.S. immigration law that treats mothers and fathers differently when determining a child's citizenship, calling such inequality "stunningly anachronistic".

The court stopped short, however, of providing Luis Ramón Morales-Santana with a ruling that he - whose late father was a U.S. citizen - and others like him should have their citizenship determined by the easier-obtained rule for those with US-citizen mothers. Her opinion cites several landmark discrimination cases that she successfully argued before the high court for the principle that having one rule for mothers and another for fathers is unconstitutional.

"Successful defense of legislation that differentiates on the basis of gender, we have reiterated, requires an 'exceedingly persuasive justification, '" Ginsburg wrote, quoting her own opinion in USA v. Virginia. But the statute has since been amended to decrease the time requirement for those born since November 14, 1986, to 5 years in the United States, at least two of which were after age of 14.

Essentially, the court's ruling requires Congress to consider men and women, mothers and fathers, as equals in the transference of citizenship, according to the ACLU's Sandra Park, senior staff attorney for the civil liberties organizations' Women's Rights Project.

Ginsburg said the government's suggested outcome should apply in the interim: a five-year requirement under Section 1401 (a)(7), applicable to children born to unwed U.

In 2000, when the government attempted to deport him following convictions for robbery and attempted murder in 1995, Morales-Santana claimed he should be considered a citizen.

Lawyer says Cosby encounter was consensual
But jurors still heard plenty from him as prosecutors read them excerpts from his 2005 police statement and civil deposition. Steele recounted how both Constand and Cosby had referred to pills the entertainer had offered to Constand as her "friends".

A federal appeals court ruled for Morales-Santana, saying that the same rules must apply to both unwed fathers and mothers, and Morales-Santana met the more lenient one-year rule.

The case is Sessions v. Morales-Santana. Ginsburg's opinion was joined in full by Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justices Anthony M. Kennedy, Stephen G. Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan. Here, she observed, the more favorable treatment for unmarried US -citizen mothers rested on the idea that an unmarried mother was "the child's natural and sole guardian".

The law imposed different standards for acquiring citizenship for the offspring of an unwed US citizen who has a child with a citizen of another nation.

Federal law provides that a foreign-born child may obtain USA citizenship through their parents.

The ruling calls on Congress to update the law such that men and women are not treated differently, and orders the executive branch to enforce the law along gender-neutral lines until new language is adopted. The Justice Department said Congress wanted to make sure there is a strong connection between a child born overseas and the United States before granting citizenship. Here, the court declined to do what the 2nd Circuit had done, and what Morales-Santana had urged them to do, which was to rule that the shorter residency requirement for unmarried mothers also applied to unmarried fathers. And because the court couldn't give Morales-Santana the relief he was looking for, Thomas continued (in a separate opinion that Alito joined), it did not need to decide any other questions, such as whether the residency requirement is constitutional.

Monk in as Middlesbrough's new boss
Ex-NBA star Dennis Rodman to arrive in Pyongyang

Recommended

  • Ex-NBA star Dennis Rodman to arrive in Pyongyang

    Ex-NBA star Dennis Rodman to arrive in Pyongyang

    And at that initial meeting Rodman said he could bring a basketball team over to play in front of the North Korean people. The President previously tweeted: "The only American who has met with the North Korean man child is Dennis Rodman ".
    Monk in as Middlesbrough's new boss

    Monk in as Middlesbrough's new boss

    The club are believed to be edging closer to an agreement with Leeds United over left-back Charlie Taylor. He said: "It's important to make clear it was two separate situations".

    Uber Executives Travis Kalanick, Emil Michael Facing Possible Ouster

    Kalanick was well aware of Alexander's behavior according to Recode , and chose to do nothing until reports appeared in the press. Uber confirmed to the BBC that Alexander no longer worked at the firm - but offered no further comment.
  • Jennifer Lawrence's private jet forced to make emergency landing

    Jennifer Lawrence's private jet forced to make emergency landing

    However, until more details have been disclosed, he can not give his certain opinion regarding how serious the incident was. The flight reportedly was departing from Louisville, Kentucky, which is Lawrence's hometown.
    Man arrested for driving vehicle into pedestrians in Amsterdam

    Man arrested for driving vehicle into pedestrians in Amsterdam

    No further details were immediately provided, including whether police believed the incident was a terror attack. The station remained open following the incident, although the entrance near the site of the crash was closed.
    Messi Wants to Remain at Barca

    Messi Wants to Remain at Barca

    This means Messi will be at the Catalan club at least until 2021 and his new deal will include a release clause of €400m (£347.2m, $450m).

  • Warriors' Green will be on the court for this Finals Game 5

    The Warriors were called for twice as many fouls as the Cavaliers in the first quarter. (AP Photo/Tony Dejak). You've got to get off the court. "It's like, 'Whoa.' You remember what can be, what can happen".
    Iran says it has killed mastermind of twin attacks

    Iran says it has killed mastermind of twin attacks

    Tehran police said the vehicle the attackers used on Wednesday was discovered on Saturday in the city centre. The parliament hosted a funeral ceremony for the victims in Tehran on Friday attended by the top brass.

    Jury hears Bill Cosby's apology for 2004 sexual encounter

    But he said in the deposition that he did not intend to get the foundation involved in the proposed payments to Andrea Constand. An analysis of the pills conducted by National Medical Services in August 2015 determined the pink pills to be Benadryl.
  • Follow Windows Central's #XboxE3 live blog and find out about Project Scorpio!

    Follow Windows Central's #XboxE3 live blog and find out about Project Scorpio!

    Please note, this deal ends today , so you only have a limited to make the decision and buy the one you are interested in. And Sony will look to make its big splash that evening at 9 p.m., getting in the last word before the booths open.
    Hope Trump will rethink Paris Climate Accord decision: Rajnath

    Hope Trump will rethink Paris Climate Accord decision: Rajnath

    Almost 200 countries are part of the accord and have agreed to fight global warming by reducing carbon emissions. Perhaps Trump felt the need to throw red meat to his base.
    US forces assist Philippines in battle to end city siege

    US forces assist Philippines in battle to end city siege

    The military has made it their objective to liberate the city by June 12 to coincide with the country's Independence Day. Another report said the group had with them two wounded individuals believed to be relatives of the elder Maute.

Harry Kane to retain England captaincy for France friendly Harry Kane to retain England captaincy for France friendly He said: "We have a lot of competition in the more advanced positions in midfield but we've not got great cover in deeper positions in that department".

Korea leader warns North after latest missile launch House Foreign Affairs Committee, called for a "quick and thorough review" that addresses environmental concerns in South Korea. North Korea is said to possess such missiles with a roughly 100km range for use against targets including aircraft carriers.

Assassin's Creed: Origins to Release October 27, According to Leak Assassin's Creed: Origins has been confirmed not to use a button to sprint as running speed will vary on the analogue stick. In Assassin's Creed Origins , players assume the the role of Bayek who is described as a "protector of Egypt".

Life is odd prequel officially confirmed, due in August Life is odd prequel officially confirmed, due in August Before The Storm's trailer wasn't very long but showed Chloe and how life is treating her after best friend Max moved away. It'll be a three-episode series, and it appears to star characters from the first game, including Rachel Amber.

Wonder Woman buries The Mummy at US box office Wonder Woman buries The Mummy at US box office Fraser sounds slightly bittersweet when he talks about the new movie though he supported the new project. "... The Mummy is a Tom Cruise film. "It's a constant back and forth, a constant partnership", Kurtzman said.

Comey Tapes or Not? Trump Promises to Tell in 'Very Near Future' The committee also has sent a letter to Comey, asking for any notes or memoranda in his possession that would describe discussions he had with Trump.

Qatar Lauds Russia's Offer on Food Supplies Amid Row With Arab States President Donald Trump backed a move by some Arab states to pressure Doha over alleged militant financing. It said Qatar was acting in "accordance with its firm beliefs and principles".

Tapwrit wins 2017 Belmont Stakes Tapwrit wins 2017 Belmont Stakes Despite Epicharis' scratch, there will still be separate, non-comingled wagering on the Belmont in Japan. "A big tsunami maybe". The New York Racing Association said the exam revealed continued inflammation in the Japanese colt's right front hoof.

London Bridge attacker tried to rent larger truck London Bridge attacker tried to rent larger truck Media in Italy claim Zaghba was stopped by the authorities in Bologna a year ago when he was en route to Syria. London police have said 12 other people from Barking held since the attack have been freed.

Emirati diplomat to AP: 'Nothing to negotiate' with Qatar Emirati diplomat to AP: 'Nothing to negotiate' with Qatar Thursday's statement added the list would be updated with new individuals and organizations based in or funded by Qatar. Qatar vehemently denies the accustations.

Attorney General Jeff Sessions offered to resign Attorney General Jeff Sessions offered to resign Trump's executive order that banned travel from seven predominately Muslim nations was blocked by federal judges in February. White House press secretary Sean Spicer declined Tuesday to say whether Trump still had confidence in Sessions.

12-Year-Old Delivers Her Baby Brother in Emotional Moment 12-Year-Old Delivers Her Baby Brother in Emotional Moment This time around, Jacee began making her case for being at the delivery as soon as she learned her mother was pregnant again. The post by Nikki Smith has been shared more than 169,000 times and liked more than 189,000 times.

Woman says she rejected advances by actor Cosby Woman says she rejected advances by actor Cosby Lili Bernard, a former Cosby Show actress who has also accused Cosby of sexual assault, showed up in court in support of Constand. I said Andrea will need therapy, I'm sure she will need therapy from this. "He was sorry for what he did", Constand insisted.

'A star is born!' - The moment Ostapenko clinches French Open title Ostapenko was too charitable with her unforced errors, striking 23. - Venus said after winning his first grand slam title. Prediction: A quarter-final appearance for Ostapenko, who takes out at least one top contender along the way.

Turkey to Fast-Track Draft Bill Approving Troop Deployment in Qatar Turkey to Fast-Track Draft Bill Approving Troop Deployment in Qatar Turkey had initially tried to position itself as an honest broker in the dispute among the Arab states . Ali Faik Demir, a member of the Galatasaray University International Relations Department.